understanding politics, considerations

Helping the Palestinians


November 23rd, 2008 · Business, Economics, and Finance, Islam, Israel and the Middle East, Religion, World Affairs

RISHON LEZION, Israel — Likud leader Ben­jamin Netanyahu makes a good point:

Netanyahu said that nego­ti­a­tions between Israel and the Pales­tini­ans had not suc­ceeded because they were devoted to solv­ing final-status issues like Jerusalem and refugees and not on improv­ing the lives of the Pales­tini­ans. He pro­posed shift­ing the focus to the econ­omy to make it eas­ier to reach an agree­ment later on.

What has been tried until now with nego­ti­a­tions that try to reach a deal on ‘Jerusalem or bust’ has led to fail­ure, and it will again and again,” Netanyahu told the crowd. “Eco­nomic devel­op­ment doesn’t solve prob­lems, but it mit­i­gates them and makes a stronger part­ner on the other side, because it gives them some­thing to live for.”

As I wrote in a prior post in this series, the Pales­tin­ian peo­ple will need a viable state of their own before peace is ever pos­si­ble with Israel. The phe­nom­e­non of sui­cide bomb­ing is com­plex, but much of it has to do with zeal­ous, reli­gious fun­da­men­tal­ists tak­ing advan­tage of peo­ple who are poor, des­ti­tute, angry, with­out hope, and eas­ily brain­washed. If the future State of Pales­tine had a sta­ble, func­tion­ing middle-class pop­u­lace, then ter­ror­ism would essen­tially dis­ap­pear. As Thomas Fried­man the­o­rized, coun­tries that both have a McDonald’s have rarely waged war against each other. (Coun­tries need to have a large mid­dle class to have fast food estab­lish­ments, and a place with a sta­ble mid­dle class wages war less often. (When peo­ple are richer and have more stuff, they are less will­ing to risk los­ing it through con­flict. Peo­ple are more will­ing to fight if they have noth­ing to lose.)

How­ever, part of me is skep­ti­cal. I, along with most mod­er­ate observers, real­ize that Israel will need to divide Jerusalem and leave most, if not all, of the West Bank in order to have peace. I just hope that Netanyahu is not merely chang­ing the sub­ject and tak­ing these dif­fi­cult choices off the table as his party gets ready for the Israeli gen­eral elec­tions in February.