understanding politics, considerations

The End of Retirement?


June 26th, 2009 · Business, Economics, and Finance, World Affairs

The Econ­o­mist notes that West­ern­ers may need to work longer as a result of increas­ing life-spans:

In some Euro­pean coun­tries the aver­age retire­ment lasts more than a quar­ter of a cen­tury. In Amer­ica the offi­cial pen­sion age is 66, but the aver­age Amer­i­can retires at 64 and can then expect to live for another 16 years. Aver­age spend­ing on pub­lic pen­sions across the OECD is now the equiv­a­lent of more than 7% of GDP (they cost Amer­ica just 0.2% back in 1935). In some coun­tries the cur­rent fig­ure could dou­ble by 2050, to say noth­ing of the cost of pri­vate pen­sions and extra spend­ing on health and long-term care…

Whether we like it or not, we are going back to the pre-Bismarckian world, where work had no for­mal stop­ping point. That rever­sion will not hap­pen overnight, but prepa­ra­tions should start now—to ensure that when the inevitable hap­pens it is a change for the better.

It should be for the bet­ter because it is being partly dri­ven by a won­der­ful thing: peo­ple are liv­ing ever longer. Life expectancy has been ris­ing by two or three years for every ten that pass, despite repeated fore­casts that it was about to reach its limit. Cen­te­nar­i­ans used to be rarer than hens’ teeth; now Amer­ica alone has 100,000 of them. By the end of this cen­tury the age of 100 may have become the new three score and ten.

This immi­nent grey­ing of soci­ety is com­pounded by two other demo­graphic shifts. First, in most rich coun­tries women no longer have enough babies to keep up the num­bers (a prospect that may please a lot of greens but not many gov­ern­ments); and the huge baby-boom gen­er­a­tion, born after the sec­ond world war, has begun to retire. In 1950 the OECD coun­tries had seven peo­ple aged 20–64 for every one of 65 and over. Now it is four to one—and on course to be two to one by 2050. That will ruin the pay-as-you-go state pen­sion schemes that pro­vide the bulk of retire­ment income in rich countries.

Unless I am lucky enough to win the lot­tery some­day (not that I play), retire­ment sounds like another cir­cle of hell. I could not spend years not being pro­duc­tive. I enjoy it. Besides, I, like most peo­ple of my gen­er­a­tion, were already skep­ti­cal that we would ever be able to retire or that Social Secu­rity will even exist in the United States in forty years.

But the grey­ing of the West­ern world might harm soci­ety in more-significant ways than the alleged death of retire­ment. See here for wor­ry­ing sce­nar­ios of future inter­gen­er­a­tional warfare.