understanding politics, considerations

Jordan and the Palestinians


July 3rd, 2007 · Islam, Israel and the Middle East, Religion, World Affairs

I’ve always been in favor of the two-state solu­tion for the Israelis and the Pales­tini­ans. This view has formed the basis for my ongo­ing series that exam­ines the mul­ti­tude of issues in play through­out the voli­tile region.

But, fol­low­ing a low-grade civil war that has led to Hamas’ takeover of the Gaza Strip and Fatah’s con­sol­i­da­tion of power in the West Bank, I’m not sure a two-state solu­tion is pos­si­ble any­more. As much as it pains me to say this, I’m no longer con­vinced that the Pales­tini­ans are able to gov­ern them­selves as an offi­cial state.

So, let me float a new idea: The West Bank should be divided between Israel and Jor­dan. Israel annexes the West­ern edge of the area, where the set­tle­ments exist. Jor­dan receives the rest, and either annexes it out­right or allows it to remain as a semi-autonomous region.

After all, Jor­dan con­trolled the West Bank until Israel took it over in the Six-Day War. Most of the Pales­tin­ian peo­ple were actu­ally Jor­da­ni­ans before they were deemed “Pales­tin­ian.” But there are two issues: 1.) What would hap­pen to Gaza? I don’t know. 2.) I doubt Jor­dan would want an influx of mil­lions of refugees and extrem­ist militants.

What do you think?