understanding politics, considerations

Book Review: Schmoozing With Terrorists


November 5th, 2007 · Europe, Iran, Iraq, Islam, Israel and the Middle East, Judaism, Lebanon, Religion, World Affairs

hamas-gunman.jpg

Most of what the West­ern pub­lic knows about ter­ror­ism comes from one of two sources: 1.) Pun­dits and ana­lysts who pur­port to be experts but have prob­a­bly never spo­ken to a ter­ror­ist; and 2.) Official state­ments and videos from ter­ror­ists that are as insight­ful as press releases from the mayor’s office.

Aaron Klein, the Jerusalem bureau chief for World­Net­Daily, a con­ser­v­a­tive news web­site, decided to speak to var­i­ous lead­ers of Pales­tin­ian ter­ror­ist groups him­self. More impor­tantly, he inter­viewed them in infor­mal set­tings – an envi­ron­ment in which peo­ple are more prone to speak­ing the truth. Most impor­tantly, he risked his life in doing so.

Although WND is very biased and usu­ally mixes opin­ion into its news reports, Klein’s new book, “Schmooz­ing With Ter­ror­ists,” is extremely illu­mi­nat­ing — and wor­ri­some. Klein, an Ortho­dox Jew from Philadel­phia, is a good reporter when he does not insert his own polit­i­cal opin­ions into his writ­ing. His ques­tions, the ones that no one seems to ask, elicit direct and hon­est responses.

Two parts of Klein’s book were most intrigu­ing. The Pales­tin­ian ter­ror­ists who are inter­viewed in Klein’s book state that they are not tar­get­ing Israelis sim­ply out of anti-Semitism or oppo­si­tion to Israel’s occu­pa­tion of the West Bank. The Islamic extrem­ists are report­edly wag­ing one bat­tle there in a world­wide war — from Israel to Amer­ica to Europe – to estab­lish Islamic supremacy. The Jew­ish state is sim­ply what hap­pens to be in their way in the Mid­dle East. In addi­tion, sui­cide bombers and their recruiters state that they are killing Israeli civil­ians in that man­ner not as a result of a demean­ing occu­pa­tion and a lack of con­ven­tional mil­i­tary might, but merely because so-called mar­tyr­dom is the best way to gain God’s favor in heaven.

Klein’s inter­views were fas­ci­nat­ing, but I have one qualm with the book. I wish Klein had cut the parts in which he used the ter­ror­ists to bash lib­eral Hol­ly­wood celebri­ties. Actors are nowhere near as influ­en­tial as con­ser­v­a­tives think (or fear). It would have been more use­ful to cut that chap­ter and expand the ones that are actu­ally rel­e­vant and important. The focus on Hol­ly­wood celebri­ties, even for one chapter, merely causes the reader to take Klein less seri­ously. I also wish that Klein had inter­viewed Islamic ter­ror­ists in other parts of the world — Europe, Pak­istan, south­east­ern Asia, and else­where — to see if their moti­va­tions match those of the Pales­tin­ian ter­ror­ists. But that could be fod­der for a sec­ond book.

Over­all, I highly rec­om­mend Klein’s book (an excerpt is here). Four out of five stars. Just ignore the parts where he bashes Hol­ly­wood and gives his own polit­i­cal opin­ions. Focus on the inter­views with the ter­ror­ists them­selves. Those facts speak for themselves.

Note: This post replaces an ear­lier one that was, in part, fac­tu­ally incor­rect. I regret the errors.