understanding politics, considerations

Michigan Fell For It


January 16th, 2008 · Business, Economics, and Finance, Science and Technology, World Affairs

So, Mitt Rom­ney defeated John McCain in Michi­gan by telling lies:

The econ­omy and the trou­bles of the auto indus­try dom­i­nated the con­test here from start to fin­ish, with Mr. Rom­ney seiz­ing on Mr. McCain’s sug­ges­tions that the jobs lost “are not com­ing back.” Mr. Rom­ney also cap­i­tal­ized on his busi­ness back­ground and his father’s lead­er­ship in the auto indus­try to per­suade vot­ers that he was best equipped to deal with those problems.

The jobs are not com­ing back, Mr. Rom­ney – yet you still pro­vided the peo­ple with false hope:

Tonight marks the begin­ning of a come­back,” Mr. Rom­ney said in declar­ing vic­tory at a hotel rally in South­field. “Tonight is a vic­tory of opti­mism over Washington-style pessimism.”

Pes­simism and real­ism are two dif­fer­ent things. It is real­is­tic to say that Amer­i­can man­u­fac­tur­ing in gen­eral – and the auto­mo­bile indus­try specif­i­cally — will not sur­vive glob­al­iza­tion, at least in their cur­rent forms.

Amer­i­cans have always been an opti­mistic peo­ple — but that char­ac­ter­is­tic can be extremely help­ful or harm­ful. In the case of clos­ing their eyes to the chang­ing world around them, it is extremely harm­ful. Sen. McCain, how­ever, is doing what he does best:

We did what we always try to do: we went to Michi­gan and we told peo­ple the truth,” Mr. McCain said. “I am as com­mit­ted now as I have ever been to mak­ing sure that no state, whether it’s Michi­gan or South Car­olina or any­where in this blessed coun­try, is left behind in the global economy.”

He con­tin­ued: “But that global econ­omy is here to stay and it is, by its nature, con­stantly chang­ing, as you all know. To com­pete more suc­cess­fully in it we must bet­ter pre­pare Amer­i­can work­ers and stu­dents to seize its oppor­tu­ni­ties. That is how we will build a stronger and more pros­per­ous America.”

In a democ­racy, the peo­ple always get what they deserve — for bet­ter or worse. Michi­gan chose to bury its head in the sand by believ­ing Romney.