understanding politics, considerations

Lawyers, Guns and Money


July 1st, 2008 · Israel and the Middle East, Law and Legal Affairs, World Affairs

TEL AVIV — The U.S. Supreme Court makes a major rul­ing:

The Supreme Court on Thurs­day embraced the long-disputed view that the Sec­ond Amend­ment pro­tects an indi­vid­ual right to own a gun for per­sonal use, rul­ing 5 to 4 that there is a con­sti­tu­tional right to keep a loaded hand­gun at home for self-defense.

In Israel, I’ve got­ten com­fort­able around guns.

I’ve only shot a real gun twice: in an uncle’s back­yard and at a sum­mer camp. I don’t think I’ve held one in years. But one of the first things I noticed after com­ing here on vaca­tion for the first time was that guns are every­where. Most Israeli sol­diers are required to carry an M-16 strapped on their backs when walk­ing around in pub­lic, and you see sol­diers every­where since most Israelis have to do manda­tory mil­i­tary ser­vice right after high school. Many Israeli men — espe­cially in Jerusalem — will carry hand­guns strapped around their waists. Every office, busi­ness and social-gathering place has a secu­rity guard out­side, and they usu­ally have guns. (In Jerusalem, they also have M-16s.) The father and brother of a friend of mine both have stun guns in their homes.

In short, guns are every­where. I’m no longer uneasy around them, unlike most non-gun-owning Amer­i­cans, so I see noth­ing inher­ently wrong about the pres­ence of many guns in a soci­ety. It’s not like every­one is shoot­ing every­one else here all the time. In fact, vio­lent crime is very low in Israel.

But then I won­der if Israeli soci­ety treats firearms in an inher­ently dif­fer­ent way than Amer­i­can soci­ety. In this part of the world, peo­ple here are around guns all the time, and every­one grows up know­ing that he will get one right after he leaves high school. So I think there’s a healthy level of respect for guns. In Amer­ica, how­ever, I think there are gen­er­ally two major types of thought: com­plete revul­sion or imma­ture attrac­tion. Peo­ple like lib­er­als want all guns to disappear, and peo­ple like gang­sters think they are sym­bol of cool­ness and mas­culin­ity. I won­der what the pres­ence of more guns would do to a soci­ety like this.