understanding politics, considerations

Globalization and Immigration


July 8th, 2008 · Afghanistan, Business, Economics, and Finance, Dating and Relationships, Egypt, Europe, Great Britain and Ireland, Israel and the Middle East, Judaism, World Affairs

CAIRO – So I was sit­ting in the apart­ment of an Amer­i­can in Egypt over the July 4 week­end when I looked around and saw the true mean­ing of glob­al­iza­tion: In a flat world, every­thing is com­pet­ing with every­thing else. And it’s not just in busi­ness and eco­nom­ics. It is in everyone’s per­sonal lives.

One white Amer­i­can had lived in Cairo for five years and was soon mov­ing to India because he was raised as a Hindu. One white girl was born in Canada but had lived most of her life in Qatar. One Jor­dan­ian woman stud­ied nurs­ing in Egypt and was return­ing to Jor­dan to work. One Ger­man had been work­ing in inter­na­tional devel­op­ment in Afghanistan and Sudan for years. Two friends of mine, now mar­ried, were born in Ari­zona, edu­cated in Boston, and now work­ing for the U.S. Peace Corps in Benin. I am an Amer­i­can who was born in the Mid­west and edu­cated in Boston but who now lives in Israel. Another woman was born in Mex­ico, raised in the United States, and now teach­ing Eng­lish in Syria. Over the week­end, I had also met a girl who was half-Palestinian and half-Egyptian and a French woman who had Arab par­ents and now lives in New York. I could go on.

This is the future of the world.

Glob­al­iza­tion is trans­form­ing the very nature of the world. Since coun­tries are increas­ingly open­ing their bor­ders to immi­grants, peo­ple are mov­ing ever­where else for edu­ca­tion, employ­ment, a lower cost of liv­ing, and even bet­ter chances to meet sig­nif­i­cant oth­ers. (A few Amer­i­cans I’ve met in Israel have told me, half-jokingly, that it will be eas­ier to find a “nice, Jewish girl” in Israel than in the so-called JAP atmos­phere in the United States. These are their words, not mine.)

In Cairo, I saw that my Amer­i­can friends could eat a lux­u­ri­ous, multiple-course meal for the eqi­va­lent of $20, order a large beer for $3, and get a pack of cig­a­rettes for less than $2. A taxi any­where in Cairo costs no more than $10 — and the city is enor­mous. Amer­i­cans do not even have to clean their apart­ments because maid ser­vices are also cheap.

Now, com­pare this life to the United States. In Boston, I paid $600 a month for a small room in a three-bedroom apart­ment. Util­i­ties were another $50 or $100. Basic gro­ceries were another sev­eral hun­dred (and the prices have cer­tainly risen since I left). These expenses were also grow­ing at a time when wages have not been keep­ing up with infla­tion and the econ­omy is tee­ter­ing on the brink of recession. If an Amer­i­can has the option to choose between a lower-middle class lifestyle in the United States or an upper-class one else­where, I can cer­tainly under­stand why they would choose the latter.

Indi­vid­ual coun­tries no longer just have to man­age their own economies and soci­eties; they need to com­pete with those of other coun­tries as well. If life is too expen­sive in Britain, peo­ple will move else­where. If a col­lege edu­ca­tion is too expen­sive in the United States, peo­ple will study at uni­ver­si­ties abroad. (And if those friends of mine can­not find a nice, Jew­ish girl in New York, then they will look for one in Jerusalem.) If coun­tries do not adapt, then they will lose their most pre­cious resource: their people.

Even the Israeli gov­ern­ment is get­ting in on the act:

With a strong Israeli econ­omy and drop­ping stock mar­kets in the United States, the North Amer­i­can aliya [immi­gra­tion] move­ment may be on the brink of a new wave of immi­grants, said Jew­ish Agency offi­cials on Monday.

I do believe there is the begin­ning of an awak­en­ing in the Ortho­dox com­mu­nity of the impor­tance of aliya [immi­gra­tion] espe­cially dur­ing the finan­cial crunch [in the US],” said Akiva Wer­ber, senior shaliah for the Jew­ish Agency’s Israel Aliya Center.

All of the eco­nom­ics, tourist trade, and high tech­nol­ogy indus­tries in Israel have [a grow­ing] finan­cial future, despite the fears of the approach­ing reces­sion in the United States.”

In the era of glob­al­iza­tion, com­pe­ti­tion is para­mount. Every­one is com­pet­ing with every­one else for every­thing. As I wrote in a lengthy essay, this is gen­er­ally good for con­sumers as long as coun­tries and peo­ple adapt accord­ingly. We’ll see where this world leads.