understanding politics, considerations

When Nations Decline


January 10th, 2009 · Business, Economics, and Finance, China, Europe, Great Britain and Ireland, World Affairs

When­ever I think about the United States, I can­not help but remem­ber the fol­low­ing quo­ta­tion from Scot­tish his­to­rian Alexan­der Fraser Tytler on the pur­ported cycle that all coun­tries and empires go through:

From bondage to spir­i­tual faith;
From spir­i­tual faith to great courage;
From courage to lib­erty;
From lib­erty to abun­dance;
From abun­dance to com­pla­cency;
From com­pla­cency to apa­thy;

From apa­thy to depen­dence;
From depen­dence back into bondage.

I am sure that some­one, some­where has com­pared this sequence to Amer­i­can his­tory, but I can­not find any­thing. So I will pose some thoughts. As Matthew Par­ris notes, the United States might be in a period of decline.

The Amer­i­can colonies were in bondage under the British Empire. They gained spir­i­tual faith and became very coura­geous. The colonies waged a war of inde­pen­dence to gain lib­erty. Over the ensu­ing decades of west­ward expan­sion, devel­op­ment, and indus­tri­al­iza­tion, the United States gained an abun­dance of power, resources, and cul­ture that became the envy of the world.

How­ever, some­time in the mid-to-late twen­ti­eth cen­tury, Amer­i­cans became com­pla­cent. They imag­ined that noth­ing — not the Soviet Union, not Japan, not China, and not Islamic ter­ror­ists — could ever harm the coun­try. In the decades since the 1960s, Amer­i­cans, par­tic­u­larly younger ones, became apa­thetic. They did not care that peo­ple were becom­ing increas­ingly mate­ri­al­is­tic. They did not care that the United States as a whole — from the fed­eral gov­ern­ment down to indi­vid­ual Amer­i­cans — was falling deeper into debt as a result of liv­ing beyond its means. They became largely igno­rant of world affairs. Amer­i­cans did not care about the out­side world as long as they could con­tinue to live their com­fort­able lives like they had been living.

As a result, the United States became depen­dent on oth­ers. Amer­i­can depends on other coun­tries, many of which are in the Mid­dle East, for oil. Amer­ica depends on Latin Amer­i­can coun­tries for cheap labor. Amer­ica depends on China and Japan to finance the debt held by the fed­eral gov­ern­ment. Amer­ica depends on other coun­tries, mainly China, for many con­sumer prod­ucts. When­ever some­one depends on another, that per­son becomes his slave — and then the cycle falls back into bondage.

If my hypoth­e­sis is cor­rect, then per­haps Amer­i­cans are finally becom­ing embold­ened to help them­selves again. Per­haps the inspi­ra­tion and hope sur­round­ing President-elect Barack Obama is the mod­ern ver­sion of spir­i­tual faith. If this is true, then per­haps the United States will once again develop the courage to lib­er­ate itself.

Adden­dum: If you believe that this cycle is an accu­rate depic­tion of the life states of a coun­try, where would Israel be located? (Or any other coun­tries with which you are famil­iar?)