understanding politics, considerations

Freedom of Religion


October 7th, 2009 · Islam, Israel and the Middle East, Judaism, Law and Legal Affairs, Religion, World Affairs

RISHON LEZION, Israel — Over the past sev­eral days of the Suc­cot hol­i­day, Pales­tin­ian and Israeli Arabs have been riot­ing in the Old City of Jerusalem because they heard that some Jews wanted to pray on the Tem­ple Mount.

Maybe I am miss­ing a detail, but why can­not both Jews and Mus­lims pray on the Tem­ple Mount? Why are Jews banned from doing so?

On a related sub­ject, why do most two-state solu­tions call for the expul­sion of all or most Jew­ish set­tlers from the West Bank? Why would Jews be banned from there? If Israel wanted to expel all Arabs from Israel, there would be numer­ous inter­na­tional condemnations.

What hap­pened to free­dom of reli­gion? Why can­not both Jews and Mus­lims pray on the Tem­ple Mount? Why can­not all res­i­dents of a future State of Pales­tine prac­tice what­ever reli­gion they wish? As I have writ­ten, Jews should be allowed to stay in the West Bank — but they and their set­tle­ments would, as is fair, fall under the juris­dic­tion of the State of Palestine.