understanding politics, considerations

Letter from Israel: Theories of Poverty in America and Israel


September 1st, 2010 · Israel and the Middle East, World Affairs

theories of poverty, poorest country in the world, relative poverty, effects of unemployment, measuring poverty, causes of unemployment, below poverty line, absolute poverty, poor family, poverty and inequality, poverty and crime statistics, national poverty, poverty and unemployment, global inequality, life in poverty, global development, population and poverty, poverty incomeTwen­ti­eth in an ongo­ing series

JERUSALEM — As much as I love work­ing and writ­ing from home dur­ing the day, there is one neg­a­tive: The chil­dren next door.

No, I don’t hate kids. Let me explain.

Israel is a small, dense coun­try. As a result, most peo­ple live extremely close to each other. The pic­ture at the top of the post is from my neigh­bor­hood — there are three large apart­ment build­ings right next to each other. This is extremely com­mon — most peo­ple and fam­i­lies live like this unless they live in a few afflu­ent areas or on a com­mu­nal farm (known as a kib­butz). It is rel­a­tively rare for fam­i­lies to have houses unto them­selves — most live in multi-room apart­ments in com­plexes sim­i­lar to the ones pic­tured above.

Where it gets extremely aggra­vat­ing is when chil­dren are yelling dur­ing the day. Imag­ine that a child on the third floor of the build­ing on the right has a friend on the build­ing in the cen­ter and wants to talk to him. He will not walk down a flight of stairs, go across the way, and walk up another flight of stairs to knock on his door. He will not even call him on the phone. He will just yell out the win­dow until he gets a response.

It sounds like this:

Danielle!” No response.

Danieeeeeelleeeeeeee!” No response.

DANIELLE!”

WHAT?” she will shout back from the other build­ing. And then a con­ver­sa­tion will ensue amid more yelling. Now, imag­ine that this is repeated with dif­fer­ent names and dif­fer­ent chil­dren every few hours. I have been so close to shout­ing from my bal­cony in Hebrew: “Quiet! If you want to talk to him, call him on the phone!”

But I do not because I know the rea­son. It is not that the chil­dren are nec­es­sar­ily being rude — as I wrote in a prior Let­ter from Israel, Israelis are nat­u­rally more emo­tive, argu­men­ta­tive, and loud than West­ern­ers. To them, such behav­ior is nor­mal. Fam­i­lies will have entire con­ver­sa­tions by yelling through the house to each other rather than by walk­ing into another room.

Still, it really stems from the fact that the fam­i­lies of the local chil­dren are likely poor. Jerusalem is Israel’s largest city as well as the one with the high­est rate of poverty. It is partly because many of the ultra-Orthodox Jews here work lit­tle (or not at all and sur­vive on char­ity and gov­ern­ment aid) in order to study the Torah as much as pos­si­ble. It is also because most of the good jobs are located in Tel Aviv and other locations.

As a result, many peo­ple and fam­i­lies here look for any way to save a shekel (roughly twenty-five cents). Why spend money on tele­phone min­utes when it is free to yell out the window?

The atti­tude even extends into more-affluent parts of Israel since the coun­try has a gap between the rich and poor that approaches the Amer­i­can level. In addi­tion, items like elec­tron­ics and fast food are more expen­sive than in the West even after con­vert­ing cur­ren­cies. A typ­i­cal McDonald’s “value meal” costs the equiv­a­lent of $12 (the kosher meat, I hear, is shipped from Argentina). Elec­tron­ics from the West have expen­sive tar­iffs. A beer at a pub is at least $7 because most brands are imported from Europe.

In addi­tion, salaries are lower — a job that pays $50,000 in the United States may pay the equiv­a­lent of $24,000 here when one works for an Israeli com­pany. How­ever, items like gro­ceries and cloth­ing are cheaper here than in the United States (if you know where to shop). One can pur­chase five styl­ish, name-brand T-shirts — Israeli brands, that is — at a mall for $20 dur­ing a sale.

For all of these rea­sons and more, Israelis are very cost-conscious, and they love to hag­gle. The longer that me and my friends have lived here, the more we have begun to adopt their meth­ods out of habit. Here are just a few:

  • No one I know uses a dryer because elec­tric­ity is expen­sive — instead, they hang their clothes out­side. In the mid­dle of sum­mer, an entire load of clothes will dry in thirty min­utes. (Just add more fab­ric soft­ener so they do not become too stiff.)
  • Many peo­ple save cell-phone min­utes by mak­ing their per­sonal calls from their work phones. Israelis love to talk — if a boss would ever ban per­sonal phone-calls at work, the employ­ees would just laugh at him. Besides, the bosses do it themselves.
  • Few men I know go to a bar­ber. Many have shaved or extremely-short hair­cuts because, after all, it is hot — and they likely became used to the style dur­ing their manda­tory mil­i­tary ser­vice after high school. After all, it is free to run a shaver over one’s head (or to get a friend to do it). Why pay $10 for some­thing that is free? As I wrote in a prior post, peo­ple in Mid­dle East­ern coun­tries have dif­fer­ent atti­tudes towards beards — and no one has a prob­lem with any­one who is not clean-shaven or has a scrag­gly beard. Razor blades are just as expen­sive here — if not more so — than in the United States.
  • If a per­son has a car — and that is a big if — it is likely at least ten years old and would be viewed in the Unites States as a “piece of junk.” The excep­tion is usu­ally if some­one has a good-enough job that pro­vides a car and free gas. (It’s a com­mon managerial-perk here.) The rea­son is that taxes on new cars nearly dou­ble the sticker value, and gas costs the equiv­a­lent of $8 per gal­lon. (Israel, inter­est­ingly enough, imports gas from Egypt and water from Turkey.) Besides, one of the ben­e­fits of liv­ing in a small coun­try is that the public-transportation sys­tem is pretty good. Unlike in the United States, a car is not viewed as a sta­tus sym­bol — it is merely a device to get some­one from Point A to Point B.
  • Just like in my exam­ple of the chil­dren next door, another frus­trat­ing thing here is how Israelis pick peo­ple up. If a friend picks me up to go out, he will not park the car, walk to my door, and ring the door­bell. He will park on the street as close as he can — and honk. And if I am not there within five sec­onds, he will keep honk­ing. (A joke that I tell Israelis: “How can you tell that I am Amer­i­can? I have patience.”) My friend will rarely even call to say he is down the street — after all, that costs min­utes and money.
  • Out­side of a few posh areas of Tel Aviv and Haifa, Israelis hate any­thing that smacks of pre­ten­tious­ness — and it is revealed in the cloth­ing here. Most peo­ple wear things like casual, cheap jeans and T-shirts. Some­times even with holes and what­not. I have seen many Israelis in pubs that if they would walk into a down­town bar in Boston, peo­ple would likely think that they were home­less. Few bar­tenders even bother to dress to impress (for tips) — although the female ones, of course, often wear reveal­ing tops. Just like cars, cloth­ing is often viewed in prac­ti­cal terms — espe­cially since no one wants to wear fash­ion­able lay­ers in a hot desert.
  • Since poverty is rel­a­tively wide­spread in Jerusalem, most peo­ple run tabs in their local neigh­bor­hood mar­kets. The own­ers of the kiosks keep hand­writ­ten ledgers of who owes what amount.

Now, my point is not that Israelis live like pau­pers. Rather, they merely watch their sheke­lim and argurot (dol­lars and cents) intensely. I think it stems par­tially from the mod­ern his­tory of the coun­try. After all, the early Zion­ists who came to Israel toiled for years to drain swamps, plant crops, fight invaders, and build cities lit­er­ally from the sand up. No one both­ered about sta­tus and sym­bols because there was always hard labor to be done. And no one was any­thing resem­bling rich.

In recent decades, the sub­con­scious “bunker men­tal­ity” of many Israelis — whether right or wrong — fur­ther made lux­ury laugh­able, espe­cially when the econ­omy nearly col­lapsed dur­ing the intifadas of the early 1990s and 2000s. (What’s the point of buy­ing a sports car if a bomb might explode tomor­row? Why spend money when you should save it because you do not know what the future may hold?) Most Israelis live with their fam­i­lies until they are mar­ried because rent and mort­gages are expen­sive. (Prop­erty val­ues in Jerusalem, for exam­ple, are extremely high because many Jews in other coun­tries buy homes and apart­ments here even though they only live in them for part of the year. Every mar­ket is now global.)

Now, this is not to say that Israelis glo­rify poverty as some­thing noble. Far from it. (In my expe­ri­ence, most peo­ple who think in this man­ner are so-called “lim­ou­sine lib­er­als” who have never actu­ally been poor.) I imag­ine that many Israelis would agree with Sophie Tucker: “I’ve been rich and I’ve been poor. Believe me, honey, rich is bet­ter.” Still, the tribal aspect of Israeli cul­ture is helped by the fact that every­one is gen­er­ally poorer than peo­ple in the West. After all, if every­one is poor — then no one is poor (at least as far as social standing).

But Israelis, like every­one else through­out the world, are still entranced by the so-called Amer­i­can Dream. Many Israelis have never been to the United States because the process to obtain a visa is bureau­cratic and a round-trip ticket costs at least $1,000, so they only know about the coun­try through movies and tele­vi­sion. I would not be sur­prised if many think — after watch­ing the sit­com like “Friends” — it is actu­ally pos­si­ble to live in a nice apart­ment in New York City while work­ing as a wait­ress or masseuse. Peo­ple here seem dis­ap­pointed when I tell them that the gap between the rich and poor in Amer­ica is even worse than in Israel and that mil­lions of Amer­i­cans do not have basic health-insurance. (Israel has uni­ver­sal health-care.)

In light of the ongo­ing eco­nomic cri­sis, I can­not help but won­der if this is a sign of things to come in the West. Fre­quent read­ers of my blog know that I am pes­simistic on the U.S. econ­omy for var­i­ous rea­sons that I will not repeat here. If the times do not improve, then peo­ple in coun­tries like Amer­ica, Eng­land, Italy, and Spain may start to live like Israelis because they have no other choice. But we will have to wait and see.

Now, for my read­ers who know me per­son­ally: Do not worry. I am not liv­ing like a pau­per. I am lucky enough to work in online mar­ket­ing for a U.S. com­pany in addi­tion to pub­lish­ing this blog. So I am doing pretty well com­pared to most Israelis. A salary in dol­lars goes a long way in coun­try like Israel or a devel­op­ing one like India.

At least at the moment, it is eas­ier to have a good life here in Israel than it is in the United States. It is lit­tle won­der, then, that more Amer­i­can retirees are vot­ing with their feet, tak­ing their (decreased) sav­ings, and mov­ing to places like Mex­ico. In an era of glob­al­iza­tion, every coun­try and every mar­ket is com­pet­ing with every­one else for every­thing — even peo­ple. And some­times I just wish the kids next door would move as well.

Tags: